Thrive Reflection 1 - Feedback on students' design (Teacher to Students)
In Sadlers (1989) seminar work, effective feedback requires are three conditions: (1) a standard or exemplar for learners to aim towards, (2) a comparison of their own work with the standard or exemplar first by producing their own initial work, and (3) the engagement of work to close the gap (in term of skills or knowledge). I had given them exemplars of what good design looks like to make the comparison and aim towards but did not record my (1) "exemplars" progress and (2) leveraged their prior knowledge. The examplar progress is as important as the exemplar outcome. While the purpose of the random lines technique is to let students imagine an interesting shape out of random lines, there is a particular way expert and novice will draw these random lines and imagine a shape out of these random line. That is, the so-called random line is not exactly random. Thus, the importance of showing the expert progress. However, having demonstrated expert progress is not enough, ...